The headlines are full of questions:
- Do digital textbooks make a difference in the classroom?
- How effective is a “flipped” classroom model?
and concerns:
- Report criticizes rush to virtual education
- Schools offer on line classes, but challenges remain
As schools explore and then implement new technology initiatives, we face many challenges. We can look back at the one-to-one laptop programs that burst on the scene ten years ago and cost schools millions of dollars and even a greater investment in time. The results of such one-to-one programs are mixed, and I say that meaning there were positive results as well as negative.
Now with growing interest in tablet or specifically in I-Pad technology, on line learning, and e-readers, we face the same challenges. But we can also fall back on some important lessons learned.
Technology initiatives have the potential to engage learners, broaden their technology skills, and usher in cost efficiencies. At the same time, there is little evidence to find that programs improve student achievement. Furthermore, when budgets get tight, initiatives like the one-to-one program were too often abandoned.
We also have learned that there are ways to help insure success. Greaves, Hayes, Wilson, Gielniak and Peterson (2010) reported three:
- Ensuring uniform integration of technology in every class;
- Providing time for teacher learning and collaboration;
- Using technology daily for student online collaboration and cooperative learning.
Furthermore, I agree with one district official whose district went to a digital model for some curriculum delivery who said, “This wasn’t a technology initiative — this was a curriculum initiative.” I think this supports author Jim Collins’ observation about technology in the business world when he said, “Technology alone never holds the key to success.” However, “when used right, technology is an essential driver in accelerating forward momentum.” We want to consider both what students learn and how they learn. This should help us not get enamored with a device, but with a philosophy, and considering how students learn is inherent in the ICS philosophy.
Right now a committee of faculty and staff at Indian Creek is surveying the technology landscape in education. We are looking at programs involving e-readers, tablets, on line courses and curriculum including such things as web design and programming. From that work, we will begin to formulate plans and consider resources to implement those plans. We do know this – this technology initiative is a curriculum initiative and we are excited by the prospect.
As we move forward, we will look forward to engaging our community in that discussion.


